Duels, how to RP them?

Hi everyone,

London fair is coming! There is no excuse for not attending! But what is a fair without a good dueling or jousting competition? Nothing. Thanks to heaven the Mayoress thought about it. The problem is that in this kind of competitive RP is difficult who decide who wins or ho loses. So here is my proposal:
The contendants make RP about the combat (presenting themselves, telling what was their fighting style....) and a questionary is opened, people judge their RP and voted for one or the other, the one with more votes won. Evena judge can be aded to correct the result of the poll if it is too tight or if some of the players makes something strange (e.g.: unexplicalbe kung fu movements ). A time limit is set for the combat and various combats can take place in different threads.

What do you think?

Sweet